The Renegade Sirloin and the Top Sirloin are the two most affordable steaks on the LongHorn menu, and visitors often ask which one to order. They are both sirloin, both lean, and both seasoned and grilled the same way, yet they are not the same steak. The Renegade is the house favorite with its own seasoning and its own following. The Top Sirloin is the quiet workhorse that costs less and does the job. This guide compares them on price, flavor, texture, and value, so you can pick the right one for your visit.
Quick Verdict: Renegade Sirloin vs Top Sirloin
If you want the most flavor for your money, order the Renegade Sirloin. Its Prairie Dust seasoning gives it a deeper, more savory taste than the Top Sirloin, and it starts at $17.29, which makes it one of the best value steaks on the menu. If you want the lowest price on the menu and you are happy with a straightforward steak, order the Top Sirloin. It is usually priced under $20, it is lean and filling, and it does everything a sirloin should do without any fuss.
What Each Cut Is
Both cuts come from the sirloin primal, the rear section of the animal, which is why they are leaner and firmer than ribeye or strip. The Renegade Sirloin is LongHorn’s signature sirloin: a center-cut sirloin seasoned with Prairie Dust, the house blend that gives it a deep, savory beef flavor. It comes in 6 oz and 8 oz portions, with 320 calories in the 6 oz size and 390 calories in the 8 oz size.
The Top Sirloin is a more basic cut from the same area. It is lean, a little firmer than the premium cuts, and seasoned and grilled the same way as the rest of the menu. It does not have its own seasoning blend or its own following, but it is the cut the kitchen recommends when a visitor wants a solid steakhouse meal at the lowest price.
Price Comparison
Price is the clearest difference between the two. The Renegade Sirloin starts at $17.29 for dinner, and $16.29 at lunch, which makes it one of the cheapest full steaks on the menu. The Top Sirloin is usually priced under $20, and it is the lowest-priced steak on the menu. In practice the gap between them is small, often just a few dollars, so price alone should not decide the order. Prices can vary by location, so it is worth checking the current menu page before you visit.
Flavor and Texture
Flavor is where the Renegade earns its name. The Prairie Dust seasoning soaks into the lean meat and gives it a savory depth that the Top Sirloin does not have. The Top Sirloin tastes like good beef, plain and simple, and it relies on its own flavor rather than on seasoning. If you enjoy bold seasoning, the Renegade is the better pick. If you prefer a cleaner beef flavor, or you plan to add your own topping such as mushrooms or blue cheese butter, the Top Sirloin is the better base.
Texture is similar for both cuts. Sirloin is firmer and chewier than filet, and it has less fat than ribeye, so it feels leaner in the mouth. Both cuts are best at medium rare, because cooking them further dries them out. If you like your steak medium or beyond, the Renegade holds up slightly better, because its seasoning keeps the flavor strong even as the meat firms up.
Which One Should You Order?
Order the Renegade Sirloin if you want the best flavor per dollar, if you like seasoned steak, or if you are ordering the 6 oz size as a lighter meal. Its seasoning makes the smaller portion feel like more food than it is, and at $17.29 it is hard to beat on value. Order the Top Sirloin if you want the lowest bill, if you prefer a plain beef flavor, or if you are adding a topping that would cover up the Renegade’s seasoning anyway. Either way, pair it with a simple side such as a loaded baked potato or grilled asparagus, and ask for medium rare unless you have a strong reason to order it differently.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between Renegade Sirloin and Top Sirloin?
Both are lean sirloin cuts, but the Renegade is seasoned with LongHorn’s Prairie Dust blend, while the Top Sirloin is seasoned more simply. The Renegade starts at $17.29, and the Top Sirloin is usually priced under $20.
Is the Renegade Sirloin worth the price?
Yes, for most visitors. At $17.29 it is one of the cheapest full steaks on the menu, and its seasoning gives it more flavor than the Top Sirloin at a similar price.
What doneness is best for sirloin at LongHorn?
Medium rare is best for both cuts, because sirloin is lean and dries out when it is cooked further. If you prefer medium, the Renegade holds its flavor slightly better.
Which sirloin is better for a first visit?
The Renegade Sirloin is the better first order, because it shows what LongHorn does best: a seasoned, flame-grilled steak at a fair price. The Top Sirloin is the better choice when the budget matters most.
Menu items and prices can change and can vary by location, so please confirm them with your local restaurant.



