Why Steak Doneness Matters at LongHorn
Ordering a steak at LongHorn Steakhouse is about more than picking a cut. The doneness you choose decides how juicy, tender, and flavorful that steak tastes when it reaches your table. A ribeye cooked rare eats completely differently from the same ribeye cooked well-done, and knowing the levels helps you get exactly the steak you pictured when you ordered.
This guide walks through all six doneness levels, what each one looks and tastes like, which LongHorn cuts suit each level best, and how to order with confidence — including what to say if your steak ever comes out wrong.
The 6 Doneness Levels, Explained
1. Rare
Internal temperature: about 120–125°F. What it looks like: a cool red center with a seared outside. Taste and texture: very juicy, soft, and intensely beefy. Rare is best for steak lovers who want maximum tenderness and don’t mind a cool center. It works beautifully on tender cuts like Flo’s Filet, which stays buttery even with minimal cooking.
2. Medium Rare
Internal temperature: about 130–135°F. What it looks like: a warm red center. Taste and texture: juicy and tender with a little more firmness than rare. Medium rare is the most popular doneness at steakhouses, and for good reason — it keeps the steak’s natural juices while giving the outside a proper sear. If you are unsure what to order, start here. It suits almost every LongHorn cut, from Flo’s Filet to the Outlaw Ribeye.
3. Medium
Internal temperature: about 140–145°F. What it looks like: a warm pink center. Taste and texture: firmer than medium rare but still juicy, with a more developed seared flavor. Medium is a great middle ground if you like some pink but want a steak that feels fully cooked. It works well on the New York Strip and the Top Sirloin.
4. Medium Well
Internal temperature: about 150–155°F. What it looks like: a slightly pink center. Taste and texture: noticeably firmer and less juicy, with a stronger charred flavor. Medium well suits guests who want just a hint of pink. Richer, fattier cuts like the Outlaw Ribeye hold up better here, because the marbling keeps them moist even at higher temperatures.
5. Well-Done
Internal temperature: about 160°F and above. What it looks like: cooked through with little or no pink. Taste and texture: firm, drier, and deeply seared. Well-done is a valid choice — it is your steak, after all — but pick a well-marbled cut like the Outlaw Ribeye or a thicker cut like the Porterhouse, which stay more forgiving than lean cuts at this level.
6. Blue Rare (Extra Rare)
Internal temperature: about 115°F. What it looks like: seared on the very outside with a cool, almost raw center. Blue rare is a niche choice for serious steak purists, and not every kitchen will prepare it on request. If you want it, ask your server whether the kitchen can do it before ordering.
Doneness at a Glance
- Blue rare: ~115°F, cool red center, very soft
- Rare: ~120–125°F, cool red center, very juicy
- Medium rare: ~130–135°F, warm red center, juicy and tender
- Medium: ~140–145°F, warm pink center, firm but juicy
- Medium well: ~150–155°F, slightly pink center, firmer
- Well-done: ~160°F+, no pink, firm and deeply seared
Best Doneness for Each LongHorn Cut
- Flo’s Filet: rare to medium rare. This lean, tender cut shines with minimal cooking.
- Outlaw Ribeye: medium rare to medium well. The heavy marbling keeps it juicy across a wide range.
- New York Strip: medium rare to medium. Firm enough to hold its shape, tender enough to stay juicy.
- Porterhouse: medium rare. Thick cuts cook unevenly at the extremes, so the middle levels are safest.
- Top Sirloin: medium rare to medium. Leaner than ribeye, so avoid well-done or it dries out.
- Renegade Sirloin: medium rare to medium, for the same reason as the Top Sirloin.
How to Order Doneness Like a Regular
- Name the cut, then the doneness: “Outlaw Ribeye, medium rare, please.” Clear and simple beats a long explanation.
- Use the standard words: rare, medium rare, medium, medium well, well-done. Avoid vague phrases like “cooked a little” — they mean different things to different cooks.
- Mention anything special: extra char on the outside, butter on top, or a sauce on the side. Ask when you order, not after the steak arrives.
- Remember carryover cooking: a steak keeps cooking for a few minutes after it leaves the grill. If you like medium rare, your steak may arrive a touch past it — that is normal, not a mistake.
- Rest your steak: let it sit for a few minutes before cutting in. Cutting too early lets the juices run out onto the plate.
What to Do If Your Steak Is Wrong
It happens, even at good steakhouses. If your steak arrives noticeably more or less cooked than you ordered, tell your server right away and be specific: “I ordered medium rare, but this looks well-done.” LongHorn will almost always fire a fresh steak rather than argue. Don’t wait until you have eaten half of it — a quick, polite flag gets the fastest fix. For more visit tips, see our First Visit Guide and Wait Times Guide.
Doneness Tips for the Best Steak
- First time at LongHorn? Order medium rare. It is the house sweet spot and the safest way to judge the kitchen.
- Sharing a steak? Order it one level rarer than the group prefers — it is easier to cook a steak a little more than to undo overcooking.
- Ordering lunch? Lunch steaks are often smaller cuts, which cook faster — stick with medium rare or medium so they don’t dry out. See our Lunch Menu Guide.
- Pairing sides: a rich ribeye pairs well with lighter sides, while a lean filet can handle a loaded baked potato. See our Side Dishes Guide.
- Want to save? Time your visit for Happy Hour or check our Deals & Coupons Guide before you go.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the most popular steak doneness at LongHorn?
Medium rare. It is the most-ordered doneness at steakhouses generally, and it shows off LongHorn’s grilled flavor while keeping the steak juicy.
Is medium rare steak safe to eat?
Yes. Whole cuts of beef are safe when the outside is seared, even with a pink or red center. Ground beef is different — burgers should always be cooked through.
What doneness should I order for a filet?
Rare to medium rare. Filet is the leanest, most tender cut, and higher doneness levels dry it out faster than marbled cuts.
Can I ask for a steak between two levels?
Yes — “medium rare plus” or “between medium and medium well” are common requests, and kitchens understand them. Just keep it simple.
Does LongHorn use a thermometer?
LongHorn’s grill cooks are trained to judge doneness by touch and experience, and temperatures here are the standard USDA-style targets for each level. If you want precision, ask your server — the kitchen can check with a thermometer on request.
Disclaimer: This is an unofficial fan guide. Menu items, cooking methods, and prices can vary by location, so confirm details with your local LongHorn Steakhouse before visiting.


